How Baseball Lifestyle 101 Built a Loyal Fanbase with Fuego and Okendo
About Baseball Lifestyle 101
Baseball Lifestyle 101 is a brand where baseball culture thrives off the field. The Shopify-powered apparel brand has built a community of 121k+ active fans — players, collectors, and die-hards who don’t just wear the brand, but rep the lifestyle.
The Challenge
As acquisition keeps getting more expensive, the brands pulling ahead aren’t spending more to win customers, they’re designing programs built to keep them. For a community-driven brand like Baseball Lifestyle 101, the goal wasn’t just more traffic, it was turning a passionate fanbase into repeat buyers.
They focused on building a mobile app customers actually open, and a loyalty program that gives them a reason to return. Run separately, both leave value on the table. Run together, each one makes the other better.
The Solution
Fuego + Okendo: one seamless system for retention
Okendo: reviews and loyalty that convert
Okendo Reviews turns real customer voices into on-site proof, and Okendo Loyalty gives shoppers a reason to enroll, come back, and spend more. Together they lift conversion, order value, and repeat purchase rate.
Fuego: a mobile app customers open
A branded mobile app gives Baseball Lifestyle 101 a direct, push-enabled channel to their community, with no onboarding cost to launch. Fans downloaded it 130,061 times and the app now drives 16.81% of total sales.
The Results
Okendo Loyalty impact
- Loyalty members are 2.3x more likely to make a repeat purchase than non-members
- Loyalty members have a $33.50 higher AOV than non-members
Fuego Impact:
- 130k+ app downloads
- 16% of total sales via app
Key Takeaways
- Retention is the growth engine: Baseball Lifestyle 101 increased retention by turning first-time buyers into repeat customers, not by outspending on traffic.
- Mobile app + loyalty as a complete system: The app gives fans a direct channel to the brand and loyalty gives them a reason to keep engaging.
- Loyalty members are better customers: 1.9x more orders, 40.5% higher AOV, 2.3x more likely to repurchase – a 66x ROI.
“A mobile app your customers actually open, and a loyalty program that gives them a reason to. Run them together and each one makes the other better.”
Hannah Madigan
Director of Ecommerce, Baseball Lifestyle 101
Product
Loyalty
In partnership with
Build your own retention engine, funded
For a limited time, launch Okendo Loyalty and a Fuego mobile app and we'll fund your loyalty launch with up to $10,000, plus 3 months of Fuego free. Funding is limited and first come, first served.
Claim your offerKeep Exploring
-
“A high-price purchase demands high confidence—and Okendo Quizzes deliver the clarity that drives conversion.”
Rachel Laubacher Director of Retention Marketing at Lectric eBikes2,596% ROI with Okendo Quizzes
-
“We wanted to drive more brand loyalty and deepen our community without relying on discounts. Okendo made it possible by giving us the flexibility to reward meaningful engagement in a way that feels earned, intentional, and aligned with our performance mindset.”
Paul Koziol Director of Digital Product at NOBULL117% increase in repeat purchases with Okendo Loyalty
-
“Partnering with Okendo Referrals to capture and quantify revenue associated with existing customers has been game-changing.”
Cate Marques CXO at Terra Kaffe108x ROI with Okendo Loyalty & Referrals
-
“When we launched with Okendo, being able to reward past purchases was a game changer. Our customers immediately embraced it, and it’s become a major driver of revenue. Okendo continues to surpass our expectations.”
Gabrielle Noakes Ecommerce Manager at Dixxon$21.1M incremental revenue generated with Okendo Loyalty
-
“Because our products are everyday essentials, repeat purchase is fundamental to our business. Okendo helps us reward that behavior in a way that feels natural and sustainable.”
Marguerite Sun Head of eCommerce at NEIWAI1,122% ROI with Okendo Loyalty
-
“By leveraging Okendo Surveys, Kut from the Kloth can make more informed decisions, optimize engagement strategies, and strengthen customer relationships—all while maintaining a frictionless and efficient feedback loop.”
Neil Popkin Vice President at Brand.co102x ROI from Okendo Surveys
-
“Okendo stands out as a truly consolidated platform built from the ground up, offering a one-stop solution for merchants seeking market-leading features and results. That’s why Andzen is proud to partner with Okendo to create meaningful customer experiences for Shopify brands.”
Jason Anderson Chief Operating Officer at Andzen11% increase in conversion rate with Okendo Loyalty
