How Baseball Lifestyle 101 Gets First-Time Buyers to Come Back

Loyalty members are 2.4x more likely to buy again than non-members, and spend about 25% more per order. Learn exactly how they built it.

Tuesday, December 15th, 2026 | 2PM ET / 11AM PT


Secure your spot

You'll get: Tick Mark Recording Tick Mark Live access

Overview

Most DTC brands pay to win a first order, then watch most of those customers never come back.

Baseball Lifestyle 101, a baseball apparel brand built on drops and new releases, found a way around it. Since moving its loyalty program to Okendo, its customer base has tripled, and its repeat rate still went up. Usually, more new customers drags the repeat rate down.

Hannah will share how they did it: the tiers, the rewards, and the points events that keep fans coming back between drops. And what still applies if your brand doesn’t run drops at all.

Bring your questions. She’s answering them live. Plus, we’re giving five brands that register a $100 Baseball Lifestyle 101 gift card.

What you’ll learn

  • How BL101 designed its tiers, and why nearly 2x as many members reached Gold as planned
  • How they keep fans engaged between drops, from points for SMS signups to double and triple points days
  • How they’re building exclusive, earn-only gear into their rewards
  • How they get members to their first reward redemption
  • What switching loyalty platforms was actually like, and what Hannah would do differently
  • Live Q&A

Frequently Asked Questions

45 minutes—including the live Q&A with Hannah Zaiff Madigan, Senior Director of E-Commerce at Baseball Lifestyle 101
Yes. Everyone who registers gets the on-demand recording after the event. If you want to ask Hannah a question, join live.
Not at all. It’s built for DTC brands on Shopify, whether you run loyalty on another platform, are thinking about starting a program, or already use Okendo.
Yes. We’re giving five registered brands a $100 Baseball Lifestyle 101 gift card. We’ll email winners after the event, and they’ll need to reply to claim their prize.

Looking for more Loyalty resources?

Learn from top brands in ecommerce and discover their top loyalty strategies

Discover Loyalty with Okendo

Fuel your fandom

Grow faster, grow smarter.